The U.S. freight market continues to face cyclical and structural challenges, with trucking volumes declining for the tenth consecutive quarter. According to the latest U.S. Bank Freight Payment Index, released on Tuesday, shipment volumes dropped by 4.7% in Q4 2024 compared to the previous quarter, while spending by shippers declined by 2.2%.
Industry experts suggest that a combination of factors, including ongoing manufacturing sector weakness and structural shifts in freight transportation, has contributed to this prolonged downturn. However, signs of stabilization are emerging, raising the possibility of a gradual recovery in 2025.
Manufacturing Slowdown Weighs on Truck Freight Volumes
The persistent softness in the manufacturing sector has been a major factor behind the trucking industry’s struggles. According to Bob Costello, chief economist at the American Trucking Associations, the downturn in factory output has had a disproportionate impact on freight demand, as a significant portion of truck shipments are tied to industrial production.
Factory output in Q4 declined between 0.3% and 0.6% compared to the previous quarter and fell between 0.5% and 0.9% year-over-year. While these declines may appear modest, they have a significant effect on trucking demand due to the industry’s reliance on industrial shipments.
“It’s clear there are both cyclical and structural challenges remaining as we look for a truck freight market reboot,” Costello stated. “Factory output softness is currently weighing heavily on our industry.”
Unlike retail goods, which may be transported only a few times before reaching consumers, manufactured goods tend to move through multiple trucking routes, amplifying the impact of industrial slowdowns on the freight sector.
Structural Changes: Private Fleets and Capacity Constraints
Beyond cyclical challenges, structural shifts in the trucking industry have also contributed to weaker demand for for-hire freight services. During the COVID-19 pandemic, many shippers expanded their private fleets to mitigate supply chain disruptions and high freight rates.
As demand has cooled, these companies have prioritized using their own transportation networks, reducing their reliance on third-party trucking firms. The shift toward private fleets has had a long-term effect on the for-hire trucking industry, limiting growth opportunities for independent carriers.
“As a result, the carriers operating these private fleets ended up shipping less with for-hire fleets in an effort to keep their drivers and trucks busy during this period,” the report noted.
Fuel Prices and Freight Spending Trends
While freight volumes declined sharply in Q4 2024, the decline in freight spending was less pronounced. This trend suggests that per-shipment costs may have increased, possibly due to higher operational expenses and reduced trucking capacity.
“Sequentially, the U.S. Bank National Shipments Index contracted more than spending, suggesting that spend-per-truck freight shipment was actually up,” the report stated.
The less severe drop in spending relative to shipment volumes may indicate that trucking capacity is tightening, which could lead to rate stabilization in the coming months.
Additionally, fuel price fluctuations have played a role in the shifting cost dynamics of freight transportation. Lower fuel surcharges, driven by falling diesel prices in late 2024, contributed to the overall decrease in freight spending. However, if fuel prices rebound in 2025, it could lead to higher transportation costs for shippers.
Regional Variations in Freight Activity
The freight downturn has not been uniform across all regions. Some areas have experienced sharper declines in shipments, while others have shown resilience in specific transportation segments.
For example:
- West Coast freight activity saw steeper declines, reflecting weaker import volumes and slower port activity.
- Midwest trucking demand remained under pressure due to manufacturing weakness and reduced agricultural exports.
- Southeastern states experienced relatively stable freight volumes, benefiting from population growth and construction activity.
The interplay between regional economic trends and trucking demand underscores the complexity of the freight market’s current challenges.
Signs of Potential Stabilization in 2025
Despite the prolonged downturn, some indicators suggest the trucking industry may be approaching a turning point.
One positive sign is that the year-over-year decline in shipments (15.7%) in Q4 was the smallest decrease recorded in 2024. This suggests that the worst of the downturn may be easing, setting the stage for potential stabilization in 2025.
Additionally, as interest rates decline and consumer demand stabilizes, the freight market could benefit from higher shipment volumes in the latter half of the year.
However, uncertainties remain, particularly regarding trade policy, fuel price volatility, and broader economic conditions.
What’s Next for the Trucking Industry?
The road to recovery for the trucking industry will depend on several key factors:
- Manufacturing Recovery – A rebound in industrial production will be crucial in driving higher freight volumes.
- Capacity Adjustments – If excess trucking capacity is reduced, freight rates could stabilize or increase.
- Private Fleet Utilization – Shippers may eventually return to for-hire trucking services if private fleet costs become unsustainable.
- Fuel Price Trends – Rising diesel prices could pressure freight costs, while lower prices would support trucking margins.
- Economic Growth and Trade Policies – A stronger economy and stable trade relationships would provide tailwinds for freight demand.
While challenges persist, the trucking industry remains a critical component of the U.S. supply chain, and gradual improvements in economic conditions could pave the way for a more stable freight market in 2025.
For latest Business and Finance News subscribe to Globalfinserve, Click here.